--- title: What Happens When a Defect is Reported but Not Made Safe? description: Sefton Magistrates court handed down a £133K fine to waste management company Viridor when a worker’s finger was amputated by a defective set of cutters. image: https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine-1.jpg --- [![SG World](https://blog.sgworld.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/SGWorld_December2020/images/sg_world_logo_new_373x208.png?width=1000&height=1043&name=sg_world_logo_new_373x208.png "SG World")](https://www.sgworld.com/) [Login](https://www.sgworld.com/account/login) - For Business - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Sector - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/construction-industry) - [Food Industry](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/food-processing-safety) - [Logistics](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/logisticswarehouselanding) - [Waste & Recycling](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/waste-recycling-industry) - [ElectIT](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/electit) - Workplace Safety - [Pre-Use Safety Inspections](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-daily-inspections) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [Key Control](https://www.sgworld.com/products/key-control-system-standard-250-slips) - [Lock Out Tag Out](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lock-out-tag-out) - [Near Miss Report Book](https://www.sgworld.com/products/near-miss-report-book) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Stationery](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - [For Education](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/education) - Safeguarding & Pupil Welfare - [Authorised Absence](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/authorised-absence) - [Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-incident-reporting) - [Latecomers Registration](https://www.sgworld.com/products/latecomers-registration-high-school-packs-of-250) - [Medicine Administration](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-medicine-administration-in-schools-record-book) - [Toilet & Continence Record Book](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-toilet-and-continence-record-book) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-school-visitor-pass) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/4dvisitor-for-schools) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management-software) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Administration & Finance - [Asset Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/asset-management) - [Cheques](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/cheque-landing-page) - [Cash Collection Envelope](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-cash-collection-envelopes-packs-of-1000) - [Good Received System](https://www.sgworld.com/products/goods-received-system-packs-of-250) - [Message & Absence Notebook](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-telephone-message-and-absence-notification-system-pad-of-120) - [School Receipt Pad](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-receipt-pad-packs-of-5) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/wallets) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - Safety Signage - [All Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/all-safety-signage) - [Warning & Hazard](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/warning-hazard-safety-signage) - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/construction-safety-signage) - [Fire Safety](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/fire-safety-signage) - [Access & Traffic](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/access-traffic-safety-signage) - [Safety Notice Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/site-safety-notice-boards) - [Floor Safety Mats](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/safety-mats) - [Inspection Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/inspection-safety-signage) - 5D Software - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-schools) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Asset Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-schools) - [Accident & Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-accident-incident-reporting) - [About Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/why-sgworld) - Resources - [Blog](https://blog.sgworld.com/) - [Permits To Work Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-information) - [Pre-Use Inspection Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-safety-inspections) - [School Accident and Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-accident-reporting) - [School Asset Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-asset-management) - [Visitor Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management) - [Free Poster Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/workplace-safety-posters) [Login](https://www.sgworld.com/account/login) - For Business - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Sector - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/construction-industry) - [Food Industry](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/food-processing-safety) - [Logistics](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/logisticswarehouselanding) - [Waste & Recycling](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/waste-recycling-industry) - [ElectIT](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/electit) - Workplace Safety - [Pre-Use Safety Inspections](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-daily-inspections) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [Key Control](https://www.sgworld.com/products/key-control-system-standard-250-slips) - [Lock Out Tag Out](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lock-out-tag-out) - [Near Miss Report Book](https://www.sgworld.com/products/near-miss-report-book) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Stationery](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - [For Education](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/education) - Safeguarding & Pupil Welfare - [Authorised Absence](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/authorised-absence) - [Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-incident-reporting) - [Latecomers Registration](https://www.sgworld.com/products/latecomers-registration-high-school-packs-of-250) - [Medicine Administration](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-medicine-administration-in-schools-record-book) - [Toilet & Continence Record Book](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-toilet-and-continence-record-book) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-school-visitor-pass) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/4dvisitor-for-schools) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management-software) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Administration & Finance - [Asset Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/asset-management) - [Cheques](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/cheque-landing-page) - [Cash Collection Envelope](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-cash-collection-envelopes-packs-of-1000) - [Good Received System](https://www.sgworld.com/products/goods-received-system-packs-of-250) - [Message & Absence Notebook](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-telephone-message-and-absence-notification-system-pad-of-120) - [School Receipt Pad](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-receipt-pad-packs-of-5) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/wallets) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - Safety Signage - [All Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/all-safety-signage) - [Warning & Hazard](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/warning-hazard-safety-signage) - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/construction-safety-signage) - [Fire Safety](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/fire-safety-signage) - [Access & Traffic](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/access-traffic-safety-signage) - [Safety Notice Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/site-safety-notice-boards) - [Floor Safety Mats](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/safety-mats) - [Inspection Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/inspection-safety-signage) - 5D Software - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-schools) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Asset Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-schools) - [Accident & Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-accident-incident-reporting) - [About Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/why-sgworld) - Resources - [Blog](https://blog.sgworld.com/) - [Permits To Work Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-information) - [Pre-Use Inspection Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-safety-inspections) - [School Accident and Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-accident-reporting) - [School Asset Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-asset-management) - [Visitor Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management) - [Free Poster Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/workplace-safety-posters) June 27, 2019 Lisa Robinson Updated on: March 4, 2021 # What Happens When a Defect is Reported but Not Made Safe? **![SentencingGuidelinesFine-1](https://blog.sgworld.com/hs-fs/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine-1.jpg?width=1000&name=SentencingGuidelinesFine-1.jpg)Sefton Magistrates court handed down a £133K fine to waste management company Viridor when a worker’s finger was amputated by a defective set of cutters. The Viridor St Helen’s site** dismantles small and large domestic appliances in accordance with the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Regulations 2013. Employee Alan Tabern was working on a line dismantling fridges using hydraulic cutters when they developed a defect and stopped working properly. Tabern reported the defect, but the HSE investigation found that the procedure for isolating defective equipment and making it safe was not followed. Instead, the cutters were left close to where Tabern was working. When he attempted to move them out of the way, they cut off the top of the index finger on his right hand and partially severed another finger. If the defect reporting procedure had included some sort of clear visual sign identifying the fault and warning employees not to use the unsafe equipment this accident may have been prevented. SG World’s [pre-use inspection solutions](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-safety-inspection-solutions) feature a safety checklist used in tandem with a high vis pass/fail notice display. This identifies that the equipment isn’t safe to use to workers and that equipment is being checked and reported to supervisors.   Catherine Lyon, HSE inspector, said: “The life changing injuries caused by this accident could have been avoided if the procedure for the safe lock-off and isolation of equipment had been followed. “Employers should ensure their safety procedures remain effective by monitoring their use and checking that they are being fully implemented.” ### About Lisa Robinson Lisa - word smith to the gods. ### Latest Reads [Catch SG World at HSM Live Coventry This Week Jun 30, 2026](https://blog.sgworld.com/catch-sg-world-at-hsm-live-coventry-this-week) [Daily Vehicle Lift Safety Checks: PUWER Compliance for Garages Jun 29, 2026](https://blog.sgworld.com/daily-vehicle-lift-safety-checks-puwer-compliance-for-garages) ### Categories - [Health & Safety](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/health-safety) - [Education Solutions](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/education-solutions) - [Safety Inspections](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/safety-inspections) - [Visitor Health and Safety](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-health-and-safety) - [Visitor Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-management) - [Asset Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/asset-management) - [Contractor Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/contractor-management) - [Public Sector News](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/public-sector-news) - [School Safeguarding](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/school-safeguarding) - [Permit to work](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/permit-to-work) - [Case Study](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/case-study) - [Academies](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/academies) - [Inventory](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/inventory) - [Forklifts](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/forklifts) - [LOTO](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/loto) - [Visitor touchscreen](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-touchscreen) - [5D](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/5d) - [Construction](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/construction) - [HSE](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/hse) - [News](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/news) ## Follow us [mailto:web-enquiries@sgworld.com](mailto:web-enquiries@sgworld.com) ## Navigate - [Home](https://www.sgworld.com/) - [Search](https://www.sgworld.com/search) ## Contact - [Contact Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contact-us-general) - [Request a Visit](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/arrange-a-visit) - [SG World Around the Globe](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/sgworld-around-the-globe) ## Support - [Software Support](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/support-centre) - [Shipping & Returns](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/shipping-and-returns) ## Legal - [Terms & Conditions](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/terms-and-conditions) - [Cookie & Privacy Policy](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/terms-and-conditions) - [Shipping & Returns](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/shipping-and-returns) Copyright © 2020 SG World. We are open Monday to Friday from 8am to 4pm. Give us a call on 01270 588211 ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Lisa Robinson", "url" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/author/lisa-robinson" }, "dateModified" : "2021-03-04T07:58:47.365Z", "datePublished" : "2019-06-26T23:00:00.000Z", "headline" : "What Happens When a Defect is Reported but Not Made Safe?", "image" : [ "https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine-1.jpg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/blogs/news/what-happens-when-a-defect-is-reported-but-not-made-safe", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SG%20World%20Logo%20(002).png" }, "name" : "SG World " } } ```