--- title: Court of Appeal Upholds the Corporate Veil Principle in BNHL Ruling description: In 2018, the courts handed down a fine of £3 million to BUPA Care Homes (BNH) Limited, a subsidiary of BUPA, in respect of health and safety failings in th image: https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine.jpg --- [![SG World](https://blog.sgworld.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/SGWorld_December2020/images/sg_world_logo_new_373x208.png?width=1000&height=1043&name=sg_world_logo_new_373x208.png "SG World")](https://www.sgworld.com/) [Login](https://www.sgworld.com/account/login) - For Business - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Sector - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/construction-industry) - [Food Industry](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/food-processing-safety) - [Logistics](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/logisticswarehouselanding) - [Waste & Recycling](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/waste-recycling-industry) - [ElectIT](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/electit) - Workplace Safety - [Pre-Use Safety Inspections](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-daily-inspections) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [Key Control](https://www.sgworld.com/products/key-control-system-standard-250-slips) - [Lock Out Tag Out](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lock-out-tag-out) - [Near Miss Report Book](https://www.sgworld.com/products/near-miss-report-book) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Stationery](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - [For Education](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/education) - Safeguarding & Pupil Welfare - [Authorised Absence](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/authorised-absence) - [Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-incident-reporting) - [Latecomers Registration](https://www.sgworld.com/products/latecomers-registration-high-school-packs-of-250) - [Medicine Administration](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-medicine-administration-in-schools-record-book) - [Toilet & Continence Record Book](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-toilet-and-continence-record-book) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-school-visitor-pass) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/4dvisitor-for-schools) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management-software) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Administration & Finance - [Asset Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/asset-management) - [Cheques](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/cheque-landing-page) - [Cash Collection Envelope](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-cash-collection-envelopes-packs-of-1000) - [Good Received System](https://www.sgworld.com/products/goods-received-system-packs-of-250) - [Message & Absence Notebook](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-telephone-message-and-absence-notification-system-pad-of-120) - [School Receipt Pad](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-receipt-pad-packs-of-5) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/wallets) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - Safety Signage - [All Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/all-safety-signage) - [Warning & Hazard](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/warning-hazard-safety-signage) - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/construction-safety-signage) - [Fire Safety](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/fire-safety-signage) - [Access & Traffic](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/access-traffic-safety-signage) - [Safety Notice Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/site-safety-notice-boards) - [Floor Safety Mats](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/safety-mats) - [Inspection Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/inspection-safety-signage) - 5D Software - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-schools) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Asset Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-schools) - [Accident & Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-accident-incident-reporting) - [About Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/why-sgworld) - Resources - [Blog](https://blog.sgworld.com/) - [Permits To Work Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-information) - [Pre-Use Inspection Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-safety-inspections) - [School Accident and Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-accident-reporting) - [School Asset Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-asset-management) - [Visitor Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management) - [Free Poster Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/workplace-safety-posters) [Login](https://www.sgworld.com/account/login) - For Business - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Sector - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/construction-industry) - [Food Industry](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/food-processing-safety) - [Logistics](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/logisticswarehouselanding) - [Waste & Recycling](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/waste-recycling-industry) - [ElectIT](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/electit) - Workplace Safety - [Pre-Use Safety Inspections](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-daily-inspections) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-products) - [Key Control](https://www.sgworld.com/products/key-control-system-standard-250-slips) - [Lock Out Tag Out](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lock-out-tag-out) - [Near Miss Report Book](https://www.sgworld.com/products/near-miss-report-book) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Stationery](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/corporate-stationery) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - [For Education](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/education) - Safeguarding & Pupil Welfare - [Authorised Absence](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/authorised-absence) - [Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-incident-reporting) - [Latecomers Registration](https://www.sgworld.com/products/latecomers-registration-high-school-packs-of-250) - [Medicine Administration](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-medicine-administration-in-schools-record-book) - [Toilet & Continence Record Book](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-toilet-and-continence-record-book) - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-visitor-management-systems) - [Customised Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-school-visitor-pass) - [Off The Shelf Visitor Pass](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/off-the-shelf-visitor-pass) - [Touchscreen Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/4dvisitor-for-schools) - [Staff ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management) - [Authorisation To Work Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/products/contractor-authorisation-to-work-passes) - [Customised Authorisation Passes](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/customised-contractor-authorisation-to-work-pass) - [Permits To Work](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [5D Contractor Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contractor-management-software) - [Contractor ID Service](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/id-bureau) - Administration & Finance - [Asset Management Software](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/asset-management) - [Cheques](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/cheque-landing-page) - [Cash Collection Envelope](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-cash-collection-envelopes-packs-of-1000) - [Good Received System](https://www.sgworld.com/products/goods-received-system-packs-of-250) - [Message & Absence Notebook](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-telephone-message-and-absence-notification-system-pad-of-120) - [School Receipt Pad](https://www.sgworld.com/products/school-receipt-pad-packs-of-5) - Accessories - [Armbands](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/armbands) - [Clips](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/clips) - [Lanyards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/lanyards) - [Lanyo-yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/lanyo-yos) - [Wallets](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/wallets) - [Wristbands](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/wristbands) - [Writing Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/writing-boards) - [Yo-Yos](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/yo-yos) - Safety Signage - [All Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/all-safety-signage) - [Warning & Hazard](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/warning-hazard-safety-signage) - [Construction](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/construction-safety-signage) - [Fire Safety](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/fire-safety-signage) - [Access & Traffic](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/access-traffic-safety-signage) - [Safety Notice Boards](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/site-safety-notice-boards) - [Floor Safety Mats](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/safety-mats) - [Inspection Safety Signage](https://www.sgworld.com/collections/inspection-safety-signage) - 5D Software - [Visitor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-visitor-for-schools) - [Contractor Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-contractor) - [Asset Management](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset) - [For Business](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-business) - [For Schools](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-asset-for-schools) - [Accident & Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/5d-accident-incident-reporting) - [About Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/why-sgworld) - Resources - [Blog](https://blog.sgworld.com/) - [Permits To Work Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/permit-to-work-information) - [Pre-Use Inspection Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/pre-use-safety-inspections) - [School Accident and Incident Reporting](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-accident-reporting) - [School Asset Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/school-asset-management) - [Visitor Management Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/visitor-management) - [Free Poster Library](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/workplace-safety-posters) November 28, 2019 Lisa Robinson Updated on: March 3, 2021 # Court of Appeal Upholds the Corporate Veil Principle in BNHL Ruling ![SentencingGuidelinesFine](https://blog.sgworld.com/hs-fs/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine.jpg?width=1000&name=SentencingGuidelinesFine.jpg)In 2018, the courts handed down a fine of £3 million to BUPA Care Homes (BNH) Limited, a subsidiary of BUPA, in respect of health and safety failings in the death of an employee contracting Legionnaires Disease; in October 2019 the fine was reduced to £1.5 million on appeal. The original fine took into account the £12 billion turnover of the parent company BUPA, and the ‘economic realities’ of the group as a whole. On appeal it was argued this conflicted with a basic principle of company law, that a corporation is to be treated as a separate legal person with separate assets from its shareholder. In accepting the grounds of appeal, the court confirmed that the mere fact that a company is a wholly owned subsidiary of a larger parent does not mean that the resources of the parent can be treated as either available to the subsidiary or as part of the subsidiary's turnover. Only in exceptional circumstances will it be necessary to adjust a fine based on the 'economic realities' of a parent company. For example, in the 2018 Tata Steel case, the parent company turnover was taken into account because the economic reality was that the subsidiary would not have been a going concern without it. The Court of Appeal reviewed and approved this application of an exceptional circumstance but concluded there was no such "special factor" in the BUPA case nor was there any suggestion that BCHL would be unable to pay the fine and require instead the parent to pay it, or that it would not be a going concern without the financial support of its parent. Large corporate entities will welcome this decision reasserting the principle that the corporate veil should not be pierced when sentencing a corporate offender. Going forward, only time will tell how the courts will interpret this ‘special factor’ and how exposed corporate giants are to eye-watering fines for health and safety failings. ### About Lisa Robinson Lisa - word smith to the gods. ### Latest Reads [Catch SG World at HSM Live Coventry This Week Jun 30, 2026](https://blog.sgworld.com/catch-sg-world-at-hsm-live-coventry-this-week) [Daily Vehicle Lift Safety Checks: PUWER Compliance for Garages Jun 29, 2026](https://blog.sgworld.com/daily-vehicle-lift-safety-checks-puwer-compliance-for-garages) ### Categories - [Health & Safety](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/health-safety) - [Education Solutions](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/education-solutions) - [Safety Inspections](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/safety-inspections) - [Visitor Health and Safety](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-health-and-safety) - [Visitor Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-management) - [Asset Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/asset-management) - [Contractor Management](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/contractor-management) - [Public Sector News](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/public-sector-news) - [School Safeguarding](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/school-safeguarding) - [Permit to work](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/permit-to-work) - [Case Study](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/case-study) - [Academies](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/academies) - [Inventory](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/inventory) - [Forklifts](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/forklifts) - [LOTO](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/loto) - [Visitor touchscreen](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/visitor-touchscreen) - [5D](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/5d) - [Construction](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/construction) - [HSE](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/hse) - [News](https://blog.sgworld.com/topic/news) ## Follow us [mailto:web-enquiries@sgworld.com](mailto:web-enquiries@sgworld.com) ## Navigate - [Home](https://www.sgworld.com/) - [Search](https://www.sgworld.com/search) ## Contact - [Contact Us](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/contact-us-general) - [Request a Visit](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/arrange-a-visit) - [SG World Around the Globe](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/sgworld-around-the-globe) ## Support - [Software Support](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/support-centre) - [Shipping & Returns](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/shipping-and-returns) ## Legal - [Terms & Conditions](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/terms-and-conditions) - [Cookie & Privacy Policy](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/terms-and-conditions) - [Shipping & Returns](https://www.sgworld.com/pages/shipping-and-returns) Copyright © 2020 SG World. We are open Monday to Friday from 8am to 4pm. Give us a call on 01270 588211 ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Lisa Robinson", "url" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/author/lisa-robinson" }, "dateModified" : "2021-03-03T10:42:39.216Z", "datePublished" : "2019-11-28T00:00:00.000Z", "headline" : "Court of Appeal Upholds the Corporate Veil Principle in BNHL Ruling", "image" : [ "https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SentencingGuidelinesFine.jpg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/court-of-appeal-upholds-the-corporate-veil-principle-in-bnhl-ruling", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.sgworld.com/hubfs/SG%20World%20Logo%20(002).png" }, "name" : "SG World " } } ```